SureBright
9 min read

Black Friday vs Cyber Monday: Which day deserves your best discount?

Overview of Contents

Tring, tring, tring, tring. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the semi finals of the holiday season!

In the red corner, named back in the 1950s by Philadelphia traffic cops who were sick of the worst gridlock of their year, weighing in at $11.8 billion in US online sales... Black Friday!

And in the blue corner, the younger challenger, dreamed up in a 2005 PR brainstorm after retailers noticed people shopping from their office computers the Monday after Thanksgiving, weighing in at a record $14.25 billion... Cyber Monday!

Yes, the biggest online shopping day of the year began as people buying things on company time, plus a press release.

Every November, shoppers and half the internet place their bets on this fight. Mashable, Business Insider and every deals site you can name have a take on Cyber Monday vs Black Friday and almost all of them are written for the person holding the credit card. Nobody seems to be in your corner, the merchant who has to decide where the biggest discount goes.

So most stores end up doing what this Shopify seller noticed:

“every Shopify store basically turn into “20% OFF EVERYTHING” for 4 days in november lol and I keep wondering if that’s actually the best offer or just the easiest one to explain”

Fair question, and the scorecards don’t settle it. Black Friday sales have grown faster than Cyber Monday’s for two years running, yet Monday still holds the belt for the biggest day. Discounts are even closer. Electronics markdowns peaked at 29% on Black Friday and 31% on Cyber Monday. Two points apart is the kind of split decision boxing fans argue about for weeks.

So, is Cyber Monday better than Black Friday for your best price? We’ll go round by round, starting with how the two days have changed and what the 2025 sales data says about how much Black Friday discounts really are. Then we’ll name a winner (spoiler: it's the Black Friday and we'll talk about why in just a minute). We'll also help you borrow a Black Friday pricing strategy or two from brands that do it well, and make sure your crossed-out price doesn’t get you a lawsuit.

Ding ding. Let the fight begin.

Black Friday vs Cyber Monday: what’s different now

If you've ever bought anything on Black Friday or were even faintly interested, you might know about the in-store brawl, where people camped outside malls for doorbusters. Cyber Monday just took that tradition online.

So the actual question for the sellers became: when do shoppers commit?

In an Adobe survey, nearly half of US consumers said they believed the season’s best deals would come on Black Friday. Their wallets told a different story. Cyber Monday still brought in $14.25 billion, about $2.5 billion more than Black Friday. It’s the shopping version of swearing the diet starts Monday and then ordering fries anyway.

That means if you are saving the best deals for Monday, there's a good chance you might be selling to an emptying arena. There's also an industry divide here, with respondents saying they are planning to shop for apparel and accessories online on Black Friday, followed by toys. The match Cyber Monday is playing is entirely different, catering to an audience looking to buy electronics.

Still, let's look at last year's numbers to get a better perspective:

Day (2025)

US online sales

Growth vs 2024

Deepest discounts for

Thanksgiving

$6.4B

+5.3%

Sporting goods

Black Friday

$11.8B

+9.1%

TVs, toys, appliances

Weekend

$11.8B

+8.7%

(no category peak)

Cyber Monday

$14.25B

+7.1%

Electronics, apparel, computers

Monday is still the heavyweight, but Friday is the one putting on muscle faster. For the full round-by-round breakdown, we covered the numbers in detail in Black Friday vs Cyber Monday: What the data reveals.

Is Cyber Monday better than Black Friday for your best price?

Here’s our call: put your best price on Black Friday (or open with it on Thanksgiving), and never beat it on Cyber Monday.

I'll tell you why. Let's think of a buyer named Alvin. He buys your espresso machine at 25% off on Friday morning. On Monday, he gets your email announcing 35% off the same machine. Alvin now has three options: ask for a price adjustment, return it and buy it again, or stay quietly annoyed until next November. So yes, none of those options is great for you.

Going deeper on Monday punishes your most eager buyers and teaches everyone to wait. That’s exactly the fear this small business owner ran into while researching:

“Some people say discounts just train customers to wait for sales and kill your margins. Others say customers don’t even believe the deals are real anymore.”

So, before you plan Monday, just ask yourself: if my Friday buyer saw my Monday offer, would they feel cheated? If the answer is yes, change Monday’s offer, not Friday’s.

Interestingly, Apple has been asking the same question for years. Its 2025 shopping event ran from Black Friday through Cyber Monday with the same gift card offer on all four days, so nobody who bought on Friday had a reason to sulk on Monday.

Cyber Monday is still worth showing up for. It just needs a different move: a bundle, a free add-on, a perk only for existing customers, or a “last call” on the same Friday price. One sensible exception is if you sell TVs or appliances. Black Friday is when the big-box stores throw their hardest punches in those categories, so a smaller store may get more attention by timing its push just before or after them.

How much discount should you offer?

If you’re wondering how much Black Friday discounts actually are, it depends on what you sell. Across the 2025 season, Adobe found the deepest markdowns in electronics (30.9% off listed price), toys (29.6%) and apparel (25.1%). TVs (24.3%) and computers (23.4%) landed in the middle. The lightweights were sporting goods at 20.3%, appliances at 20.2% and furniture at 18.8%. So if you sell sofas or dishwashers, a “40% OFF” banner is roughly double what shoppers saw across your whole category. On Cyber Monday specifically, Adobe recorded electronics at 31%, toys at 28% and apparel at 25%, with furniture and appliances at 19% and sporting goods at just 17%.

Even customers side with this range -

Random fun fact - Adobe’s own wrap-up said discounting generally peaked on Black Friday across categories.

Who are you actually throwing the discount at?

This one merchant raised the right question on r/ecommerce:

“Unless your CRM game is on point.. Black Friday is for those customers bargain shopping.. and price comparing. What would the gain be in customer growth?”

That's a question worth losing a night's sleep over. But I've got the answer. Actually, the size of your discount decides which customers walk through the door, and research suggests that choice lasts long after the weekend.

One study found that customers acquired with a 35% discount were worth about half as much over time as full-price customers. Why? Some shoppers attracted by a steep discount may never be willing to pay the regular price. An earlier study found the opposite, though, so discount buyers aren’t always less valuable. The risk is worth keeping in mind.

If yours can tell past buyers from first-timers, give your deepest offer to the people who already know and trust you. Bringing back a past customer with a discount is usually a better trade than renting a stranger who’ll leave once prices go back up.

Black Friday pricing strategy: Moves that other brands use

Let's open the playbook and steal the best moves without starting a price war:

  • Let your list in early - One of the most practical tips is letting email subscribers and customers shop your sale three or four days early with a code. Your loyal buyers get first pick, and you collect their sales before your competitors’ ads flood every feed.
  • Give value instead of cutting price - Apple almost never lowers its sticker price. It hands out gift cards worth up to $250, which brings people back to spend them later. A store credit does the same job for a smaller shop and keeps your regular price intact.
  • Promise the price won’t drop later - Target’s Holiday Price Match Guarantee ran from November 1 to December 24 in 2025. If something a shopper bought went cheaper at Target later in the season, Target paid back the difference. Early buyers lose nothing by buying early, so they stop waiting. Best Buy ran a similar guarantee and stretched its holiday return window into mid-January.
  • Attach a condition to the discount - IKEA turned Black Friday into Buy Back Friday in 2020. Customers brought back old IKEA furniture and got store credit, and IKEA Family members got double the buyback amount. The discount only goes to people who take an extra step, so bargain hunters who would never return are mostly filtered out. Trade-ins, loyalty-only pricing and “bring a friend” offers do the same job for smaller stores.
  • Give a little back instead of cutting the price - Everlane mostly sits out normal Black Friday sales. Instead, it runs its Black Friday Fund, donating to a charity for every purchase made that weekend. It also has a “Choose What You Pay” section, where shoppers pick from several prices on selected items. That’s a neat way to clear overstock while your main catalog keeps its regular price.

So, what happens after the final bell?

Well? Who wins the Cyber Monday vs Black Friday bout? For your best price, Black Friday, by a decision rather than a knockout. Put your strongest discount there, keep Monday from undercutting it, and aim your deepest offers at customers who’ll still be around in February.

There’s one more move, though... instead of cutting the price again on Monday, add something worth more than the extra discount. A TV or a laptop bought in late November is exactly the kind of purchase shoppers worry about when the warranty card falls out of the box. Bundling accidental damage protection into your Cyber Monday offer gives buyers a reason to choose you over the store two clicks away. Your Friday price stays intact, and the customer has a reason to come back to you if something goes wrong.

SureBright helps merchants add customized protection plans to checkout without the headache of building a program themselves.

Want to see how it works? Schedule a demo with our team or learn how much you can earn.

Author

Khizar Mohd

M Khizar is a writer who enjoys making complicated things feel simple. He writes about warranties, e-commerce, and the small details people usually overlook until they matter. His work focuses on clarity and helping readers make smarter decisions without overthinking it. Outside of work, he enjoys reading, writing personal blogs, and binge eating with friends.

Recent blogs

View all blogs